Flow Trading
- Core mechanisms: The firm acts as the main dealer. The goal is to profit from the spread and turnover volume.
- Capital deployed: The firm’s capital holds temporary inventory.
- Risk profile: Moderate market risk. Heavily hedged
- Client interaction: Essential. The entire operation relies on serving clients and absorbing their liquidity needs.
- Regulatory status: Widely permitted and recognized globally within investment banks as a critical market-making function.
Proprietary Trading
- Core mechanisms: Directional bets based on technical analysis. The goal is to profit from asset appreciation.
- Capital deployed: Firm capital funds speculative investments.
- Risk profile: High market risk. Positions remain open for much longer, being more vulnerable to macroeconomic shocks and unexpected events.
- Client interaction: The operations are isolated from external order flow. The desk acts as an internal and self-directed hedge fund.
- Regulatory status: Since 2008, heavily restricted within commercial banks. These activities are mainly restricted to specialized and independent trading firms.
How Does Flow Trading Generate Profits?
The profit from this operation is found in the bid-ask spread. The bid is the purchase price, while the ask is the selling price.
The firm quotes these 2 different prices to the market and the difference is the gross profit margin per unit traded.
When the market becomes more volatile, the spread widens to compensate the dealer for an increased risk for holding assets.
Dealers have to take on the risk that their counterparty could hold superior information and leave them at a disadvantage. They also need compensation for the risk they take for holding the asset in their portfolio while waiting for another party to show up.
They deal with risks by using dynamic pricing adjustments. They’re able to artificially widen the bid spread and lower the ask spread to increase their premium when necessary (i.e., institutional funds selling a massive block of stocks all at once).
Real-World Examples
So, for educational purposes, keep in mind that flow trading works very similarly to market making.
The goal is to capture the spread.
Picture a scenario where a large client wants to buy a massive block of a specific stock.
Instead of routing this order to a public exchange and triggering a price spike, the flow desk steps in and facilitates the trade directly.
The firm matches the incoming order against its own inventory.
If the firm already holds those shares, acquired previously at a lower price, they sell them straight to the client.
The desk offers a purchase price that is slightly better than what the public market displays, giving their customer an immediate execution at a good price.
At the same time, the firm secures a profit by selling the shares for slightly more than their initial cost, which works to the benefit of the firm itself and their customer.
Risk Management & Hedging
In practice, when you send a sell order to the order book, very rarely will you find an immediate buyer. The dealer will exercise that role to absorb your order.
However, once they do that, they’ll have to hold your assets in their inventory for a period of time. That can go from a couple of days to weeks. That means they’re taking on a huge market risk during this holding period.
If any macroeconomic shock happens, the asset’s value goes down, and the dealer is left with a loss.
The best way to make this operation worth it is through quantitative risk management and continuous hedging.
Dealers use mathematical risk metrics to neutralize their exposure. They use advanced concepts like the Dollar Value of a Basis Point (measurement of the dollar-change in an asset, like a bond, based on the risk-free interest rate yield curve) and Credit Spread 01 (measurement of sensitivity to a widening or tightening of an issuer’s credit spread).
Going beyond the stocks, they also use algorithmic strategies to manage important Greeks like Delta and Vega in the derivative markets.